| Date | Player | Home Runs | |
| 05/04/1951 | Joe Conrad | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 3 RBI versus Boston while playing for St. Louis | |
| 05/16/1951 | Héctor Soto | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 4 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Baltimore | |
| 07/19/1951 | Clement French | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 6 RBI versus Detroit while playing for Chicago | |
| 07/25/1951 | Lúcio Andrade | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 7 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for Chicago | |
| 08/21/1951 | Julius Herbert | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Boston while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 09/27/1951 | Brett White | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 6 RBI versus St. Louis while playing for Atlanta | |
| 09/27/1952 | Bryant Sims | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 7 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Boston | |
| 05/27/1955 | Stephen Kennedy | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 6 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 08/11/1957 | Shawn Daniel | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 3 RBI versus Pittsburgh while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 05/03/1959 | Roberto Prado | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 6 RBI versus Pittsburgh while playing for Atlanta | |
| 09/28/1959 | Alonso Cruz | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 6 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 04/23/1960 | Chut-sai Li | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 6, 4 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 06/19/1960 | Shawn Daniel | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 7 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Philadelphia | |
| 07/16/1960 | Ian Turina | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 8 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 08/04/1960 | Víctor Martínez | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 4 RBI versus Chicago while playing for Boston | |
| 06/05/1961 | Andre Parkinson | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 3 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 06/18/1962 | Mike Caldwell | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 4, 6 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for St. Louis | |
| 08/03/1962 | Mike Fox | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 6 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 04/25/1963 | Alberto Pérez | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 5 RBI versus Baltimore while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 08/30/1964 | Daniel Mullholland | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 4, 3 RBI versus Chicago while playing for Washington | |
| 07/24/1965 | Larry Jackson | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 5 RBI versus Boston while playing for Detroit | |
| 09/25/1965 | José Cedeño | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Chicago | |
| 06/23/1967 | Chut-sai Li | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 6 RBI versus Washington while playing for Detroit | |
| 05/12/1968 | Dave McGrath | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 6 RBI versus St. Louis while playing for Manhattan | |
| 07/01/1970 | Chut-sai Li | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Chicago | |
| 07/08/1970 | Vincent Hughes | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 4 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for Cleveland | |
| 07/23/1970 | Carlos Rivera | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 5 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 08/04/1971 | José Corral | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Chicago | |
| 08/12/1971 | Oscar Norman | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 6 RBI versus Baltimore while playing for Cleveland | |
| 07/16/1972 | Bartolo Zavala | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus Boston while playing for Washington | |
| 08/23/1972 | Vincent Hughes | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 3 RBI versus New York while playing for Cleveland | |
| 05/21/1975 | Dave Walker | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Boston | |
| 04/25/1976 | Rusty Tillman | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 5 RBI versus Phoenix while playing for The Bronx | |
| 06/06/1977 | Tyler Anderson | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 4, 6 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for San Antonio | |
| 06/12/1977 | Vincent Hughes | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus Detroit while playing for Cleveland | |
| 06/20/1977 | Lúcio Ayala | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 7 RBI versus Houston while playing for Cleveland | |
| 08/10/1978 | Iván Salas | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 4 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Boston | |
